Friday, September 11, 2009

Top Chef Vegas

Top Chef Season Whatever has begun again without a chef or cook from New Orleans. But hey two people from Atlanta made it and Atlanta is the New York of the South. After 4 weeks, two things are abundantly clear. First, the casting agency found 6 people who could cook, and then stopped doing their job. Second, Ashley will go extremely far in this competition by following Lisa from Season 4's lead.

The Brothers Volt, Jen Ripert, Mike from Juhsey, and the Baconator are the only people who should win. The rest of them as a whole have been mostly disappointing. You mean to tell me in a nation where cooks are being laid off at record pace, the casting agency hired by Magical Elves could only find 6-7 chefs who could really win this thing? Was there no one better than Eve? Shoot, I bet Petro from P&G on Baronne could have gone farther than Lip Ring Girl.

The first contestant to go, whose name is irrelevant, looked like a cast off on Miami Ink. Listen, I understand chefs and cooks come from a different world than normal people. But if you were eating a restaurant and that lady walked out with ear lobes you could drive the Madden Bus through and a Tyson worthy tattoo job, don't you think that might turn off your dining experience. It was difficult to watch and I imagine for the judges even worse to experience her cooking.

Ashley, who is the embodiment of a Killers song, will go very far in this competition despite any skill. Look for her to do just enough that someone else does worse than she does. Plus, she will continue to provide meaningful societal statements in a format where it is completely uncalled for. Ashley, had you seen Top Chef before? In one season the chefs were required to cook a wedding feast for a groom and groom. Did the straight chefs air their political viewpoints and whine like you did? Instead we will be subjected to more weeks of look at this f*cking hipster cook, hurried frenzy, and dishes that apparently don't suck enough.

So early predictions look like this:

Ashley - makes it to finals, loses when she really should have won, but only because the judges this year take into account entirety of the season - in a radical departure from last season.*

Jen Ripert - Here will be the downfall of Jen. She keeps winning quickfires. Eventually that means she will have to be the captain for restaurant wars. Unfortunately for her, Eli acting as maitre'd will do something stupid like serve the red wine in a water glass. Jen will take the blame leading to Padma asking her to "Please pack your knives and go."

Eli - Hangs around and hangs around. See also Carlos from Season 1 or Ilan from Season 2.

The Baconator - Has a real shot at winning this thing. But I sense he falters when asked to cook a chardonnay and cigarette amuse for Kim from The Real Housewives of Atlanta.

Ash - Gone in at least the next 3 episodes.

Brothers Volt - Each gets kicked off after old sibling rivalry over Mario 3 is reignited which leads to punches thrown.

Mattin - Just too young and inexperienced to make it the whole way.

Mike from Juhsey - This guy has a shot to be an under the radar competitor in the finals. But bravado eventually costs him the title when he decides to try his hand at cheesemaking in episode 8.

Ron - I like this guy to go far, but ultimately he does not seem to have the speed and refinement of the elites which seems to be what the judges want in a winner this season. Ron is like a monster truck racing in NASCAR.

Winner is either Jen, the Baconator, or a Volt Brother.


* Go re-watch the Season 4 Finale. Lisa freaking killed it, Blais choked, and Stephanie finished second if you listen to the judges comments.

13 comments:

Donnie Boy Riguez said...

If Ziggy Stardust (Ashley) doesn't get kicked off soon, we're looking at the same Lacey/Rock of Love conspiracy always used by the producers. She's just plain awful. And what exactly is wrong with deep frying a steak?

I've got Ripert girl all the way. She's got more balls than all of the dudes there, including Ziggy.

Real Big Tally said...

Rene,

I'm not sure if you check out the Bravo blogs for Top Chef, but Colicchio has hit on a few good points in the bast in regards to casting.

For one, I'm sure we've both noticed that the females this year (Jennifer excluded) are a rather weak lot. Unfortunately, the producers of Top Chef seem to have it set in their mind that they need to have an equal number of male and female chefs to begin a season. The fact of the matter is that there are far more male chefs out there, and thus, the pool of potential female cheftestants is diluted - creating a higher likelihood of crappy chefs on the show.

Of course, I am not suggesting that the male talent pool is something exceptional either, but let's face it. Yes, Top Chef is a cooking show but it's also about entertainment. For some reason the producers believe that the cooking isn't enough and thus must cast "characters" or reality show archetypes. Look at who we have now:

- Mike I. - The asshole/obnoxious New Jerseyian (New Jerseyite?)

- Eli - Smarmy little man.

- Ash - Jolly gay dude

- Ashley - Un-jolly gay woman

- Mattin - annoying Euro

And so on and so on.

Still, I think you're presupposing that all these talented chefs are trying out for the show. Yes, I understand no one representing New Orleans has made it on the show - and that is a damn shame - but you have to view things from the producers' perspective.

If every chef is excellent, then you lose that underdog factor that many might watch for. If every chef is professional, you lose the "I HATE that guy factor." If every chef is a dude, you get the straight male response of "Ok, I'm watching a show on Bravo with 16 dudes - I think I may be gay."

Of course, I have enjoyed nothing more this season then seeing the two V's, Jennifer, and Kevin come up with interesting dishes while working effectively both individually and with a team. In fact, if every other person feels as we do, it's very likely they'll stop casting to type and start focusing on just getting great chefs on the show.

I'd love to see a 12 person season (wasn't Season One 12 or 14 people) of exceptional chefs, but isn't that what we just got with Top Chef Masters? Top Chef has it's own formula pretty much down to a science, and I don't know if there is a real call for them to deviate from it.

Sorry for the long, rambling post. Here's the link for anyone who watches to what I find to be the best blog on the show: http://www.skilletdoux.com/

blathering said...

I actually think Jersey Mike has ZERO talent; he is just riding on the Volt brothers' coat tails.

His deconstructed sauce this week was handed to him by Bryan. He needs to go so I can quit yelling at him through my television.

Unknown said...

I think the finale of Season 4 was heavily edited to make it look like Lisa would pull the upset. I remember reading blogs from the judges that said Stephanie was the hands down winner and Richard was runner-up. They've done that plenty of times in the past, most recently when Jeff was brought back to New Orleans last year and the producers made it seem like he was going to win and make it into the finale. The judges, in their blogs, said his food tasted like sterno, but that wasn't mentioned in the episode once.

I know its not about this season, I just really needed to defend Richard.

Rene said...

Donnie Boy- Well said.

Real Big Tally- Get a job.

Blathering- I think you are correct.

Paul- Richard though at least has a good attitude about losing. His quote about how some "people look at Top Chef as a way to get a golden egg, I see it as a way to get a chicken" sums up what a stud he is.

Anonymous said...

I haven't seen anyone play a victim as poorly as Ashley has since Mary Jo Kopechne starred in "A Night in the Chappaquiddick"

Anonymous said...

I totally agree with blathering. While discussing the show yesterday I said the same thing about Mike riding the coat tails of the V brothers.

Also, if you notice from last week's potatoe quick fire he made fun of Jennifer's vichyssoise over mussells calling it "potato broth". And what did he cook on this weeks escargot quick fire? THE SAME THING.

Real Big Tally said...

I billed that time to "administrative" thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

How could you fail to mention the other androgynous female Preeti Awful?

Donnie Boy Riguez said...

Sorry for leaving out Preeti. I am just grateful she is gone.

Anyone who bad mouths Petro should be careful. He runs Barronne St. with an iron fist. If you notice, no one ever talks back to him. That's respect.

Richard and Danielle said...

Who the hell is Ron?

Richard and Danielle said...

Nevermind. He won't be around for long.

Rene said...

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The St. James Soothsayers!