Sunday, September 28, 2008

Top 10 New Orleans Sandwiches

      Nothing like starting the week off with a little controversy.

      1. Roast Beef Po-Boy - Parkway Bakery: Words cannot describe the magic of Parkway's roast beef. The beef and gravy somehow become one with each other to make for a spectacular sandwich. The only possible way to improve on this po-boy would be to add fried shrimp .... Oh, right. I believe they call that the Surf & Turf, and it's now a permanent fixture on the menu. Then again, why mess with perfection?
      2. Muffuletta - Nor Joe's: Sure, Central Grocery may have started it all, but who wants to wait in line and deal with surly service? At Nor-Joe's you only have to tolerate surly service. This sandwich is not for anyone with an aversion to the finer things in life. Things like cheese, Italian deli meats, briney olives, and bread. Its about time someone around town made a Muffuletta Charcuterie Board. In fact, I just did.
      3. Roast Duck Po-Boy - Crabby Jack's: This thing is amazing, if only for the fact that you can't get it anywhere else. Succulent roasted duck in a brown au jus - it also wins the "high class" award.
      4. Mozzarella - St. James Cheese Company/Fernando - Stein's Deli: So similar, yet so different? Both start with foccacia, pesto, and fresh mozzarella. At St. James they use salami, while at Stein's they layer on the prosciutto. The St. James Girl (surprisingly) gives the edge to the Mozzarella because the cheese is slightly melted.
      5. Banh Mi - Pho Tau Bay: The bread might be the best specimen of classic New Orleans style french bread in the city. The fillings are straight from Vietnam. My favorite is the chef's special liver sausage and rolled ham, but you can't go wrong with the char grilled pork. By the way, the sandwiches are small (and cheap) enough so that you can order both.
      6. Oyster Loaf - Casamento's: Oysters - it's what they do, which is why Casamento's is closed during those dreaded summer months when oysters are not at their peak. Piled high on toasted and buttered "pan bread" with a few pickles and a couple of dashes of hot sauce. You can't get much better than that.
      7. Meatball Parmesan Po-Boy - Mahony's: The fresh mozzarella alone catapults this sandwich to the Top 10, but the handmade meatballs and red gravy are integral ingredients of the final product. The anise flavor in the meatballs provides a sweet overture to the final product.
      8. #4 - Bud's Broiler: Onions? Yes. Double Meat? Yes. Chili or Sauce? Yes. (Wait, I said "or" - I have always been a sauce man myself, but I don't judge the chili lovers out there.) And if that wasn't enough, you can get this sandwich late at night.
      9. Fat Kid Special - Liuzza's: Have you still not tried this yet? Panneed chicken breast topped with roast beef and gravy. How can that NOT be good? And if you wanted to be really fat, may we suggest putting fried pickles on top of all that. Dear God, my keyboard just went into cardiac arrest. Someone get me a bushwacker, STAT!
      10. Italian Special - R&O's: Slices of Italian sausage and meatball, covered in red gravy, and topped with mozzarella. The seedy Italian style bread is unconventional for a po-boy, but it works. Plus, ordering a po-boy called the Italian Special makes it seem like you just put a hit out on that jerk from third grade.

      Coming Tomorrow - the sandwiches we once loved, but now they are gone.

      8 comments:

      Unknown said...

      goodgodallmighty.

      Anonymous said...

      Parasol's roast beef po-boy should be up there, other than that its a good list.

      Anonymous said...

      BC always votes for the chicken fried steak poboy at Ye Ole College Inn. Sure their new diggs have that slightly distressing hint of Katrina necessity infused with Rock & Bowl money, but you can't fault the sandwich for that. The sandwich had no say in that transaction; it just delivers what you want, plus gravy.

      Rene said...

      What a way to start off the Week.
      Who Deuce!
      And now possibly the most hunger inducing post of this blog's short career.

      Parasol's will be addressed soon.

      How did you leave the cheeseburger with grilled onions and bacon from Camelia Grill off?

      Or the $25 po-boy at Adelaide?

      I love this town.

      Anonymous said...

      What?! Where's the bacon/fried oyster sandwich from Cochon?

      Or the Steamboat from Martin's?

      Great list, though...gonna have to try the one's I never tasted...

      Anonymous said...

      Did any sandwich that involves salami or meatballs and mozzarella NOT make the list?

      The Mozzarella at St. James is actually on ciabatta, which makes it better than foccacia because it gets a crunchier crust when toasting.

      Anonymous said...

      Good work, nice post. Digg yourselves for a little self/city promotion. I am a complete sucker for a good list.

      http://digg.com/food_drink/Top_10_New_Orleans_Sandwiches

      Daniel said...

      No love for Reginelli's!? The Uptowner is a new classic.

      Clearly your list isn't long enough. You could make this up to 100 and have people vote on it, release it every year like the college list from US News. Now THAT would be fuggin amazing.